Amateur OnlyFans: 20+ Best Creators for Amateur Content on OnlyFans

What do we want? Amateur porn stars! Went do we want them? Now! OnlyFans is the place to be for porn, sex tapes and nudes of the highest quality, all from creators that are amateurs in their field. We all love a good porn actress, and have a soft spot for our favorite PornHub girls, but sometimes you want something a little different, that feels more real and raw — that’s where amateurs come in. We’ve compiled a list of the hottest amateur OnlyFans creators with the best content of the highest quality. There’s a little something for everyone too, whether you’re into milfs, blondes, BBWs or anything else, you’ll find a girl to fit your desires here. Let’s dig in!

Top 5 Best Amateur OnlyFans Models

Meet the 20 Hottest Amateur OnlyFans Babes in 2024

1. Kacy Black

amateur OnlyFans kacy black

If you’ve read our list of the best PAWG OnlyFans babes, you may already be familiar with Kacy Black. This seductive femme fatale is one of our favorite amateur OnlyFans creators, and she makes incredible sex tapes, and takes gorgeous nudes. She does solo play, dildos, fingering, and all that good stuff, as well as sexting sessions, full, uncensored nudes, and even dick rates. She’s not shy, so send her a message and get chatting about what turns you on — she loves getting dirty in private messages. Enjoy Kacy Black and her world of temptation for just $3.15 for the first month.


2. Caylin Live

amateur OnlyFans caylin live

Caylin Live has an insanely hot body, like, huge boobs, phat ass, tiny waist: the dream. As one of the hottest big tits OnlyFans creators, Caylin really gives off goddess vibes. Her body isn’t all we love about her though: Caylin also has a really beautiful face, with sculpted, angular features that make her look uniquely stunning. This impressively sexy Italian babe does everything you could want and more, and loves live-streaming her solo fun, so when you subscribe to her, you never know when you’ll get treated to some real-time magic. Caylin does customs and sexting, and believes everything is more fun when she’s being watched. Her page is one of the most popular free OnlyFans pages out there, so don’t be shy, sign up and join in on the fun.


3. Persephone Pink

amateur OnlyFans persephone pink

Who doesn’t love a gorgeous, gothic alt-girl with a phat ass? I know I do. Just look at that plump little peach. As one of my favorite big ass OnlyFans babes, Persephone Pink sits pretty at number 3 on our list of the best amateur OnlyFans models, too. As soon as you sign up, Persephone sends you loads of great content for free, including videos of anal, creampies, facials, fuck machines, and even some seriously sizzling hot JOI OnlyFans content (something that Sephy is fantastic at!). If you want to have a stunning alt goth girl rate your dick, or watch her get banged in the ass, sign up for Persephone Pink’s OnlyFans below – it’s just $9.99 a month.


4. Elizabeth

amateur OnlyFans elizabeth88

Breathtaking blonde milf, anyone? I thought so – this babe has us foaming at the mouth, barking, going feral like a pack of starved dogs. Elizabeth is an amazing OnlyFans milf, with a cute smile and a talent for pleasing. She does solo, b/g and g/g content, and already has over 3000 pieces of content uploaded to her page. She uploads new content regularly, and offers some PPV for devoted fans too – often, she will film herself reacting to (and enjoying herself to) a wide range of porn videos, which is something she’s very popular for. If you’d like to see Elizabeth get dirty on the regular, subscribe to her page for $6.79 for the first month below.


5. Samantha Flair

samantha flair amateur OnlyFans

Samantha Flair, or Sam, is a lovely Australian goddess, with big boobs, and a luscious butt. Sam has one of the best no PPV OnlyFans accounts out there, providing her fans with regular, intense pornographic content without extra charge. The best part is that Samantha is so generous, she lets you pick how much you pay for your subscription! Just message her how much you’d like to pay, and she’ll consider it. Nobody else on OnlyFans does this to our knowledge, so we love her for that. Check out Sam’s page below, subscribe, and shoot her a message to tell her what you think a subscription to her page is worth.


6. Savvy Suxx

savvy suxx amateur OnlyFans

Savvy Suxx (yes, she certainly does) is a beautiful amateur OnlyFans creator with long, slender legs, perky boobs, and a perfect ass. This luscious lady is aptly named, since she does some of the hottest OnlyFans blowjob content out there : she says “I suck dick so good I decided to go pro”, which explains her career trajectory pretty well. Savvy uploads new content daily, which ranges from HD nudes, all the way to sex tapes including b/g, g/g and threesomes/group sex. She also does customs, rates dicks, and even live streams — so don’t miss out — sub to Savvy Suxx for $10 a month today.


7. Yinyleon

yinyleon amateur OnlyFans

Yinyleon is a gorgeous, muscular mommy with phat boobs and a stunning ass. I wish she would sit on my face right now. Wait, did I just say that? Anyway, Yinyleon is obviously beautiful, and she has a kind of, viking-that-might-rip-your-head-off vibe that we’re totally digging. As one of the best amateur OnlyFans babes, you can bet she gets into some really nasty, naughty stuff on her page. Not only that, but she sells her worn lingerie and used toys, and will even rate your dick for free! Subscribe to Yinyleon today and find out why we think she’s got one of the best OnlyFans accounts for just $9.99 a month.


8. Riley Mae

riley mae amateur OnlyFans

When it comes to the hottest amateur OnlyFans creators, it wouldn’t be right to bypass Riley Mae, the beautiful blonde with some of the best OnlyFans nudes on the platform. Not only does this slender young 19-year-old post breathtaking nudes, but she also makes show-stopping amateur porn that’ll have you begging for more. Her talents really do lie in the bedroom, and watching her do her thing is a blessing. If you’d like to find out what we mean for yourself, you can subscribe to Riley below for free (yes, free) and see what she’s hiding on her OnlyFans page.


9. Killer Katrin

killer katrin amateur OnlyFans

Killer Katrin, or Kate, has two OnlyFans accounts: a free one and a VIP one. The free account (linked below) has freebies, teasers, and PPV content ; the VIP one is where she gets really filthy, for her most loyal fans. Kate posts uncensored, explicit pictures and videos, does livestreams, makes custom content, and loves chatting to her fans in private. This beautiful babe has over 3 million Instagram followers, and collectively over 700k likes on OnlyFans — it’s safe to say she’s very popular. As one of the hottest blonde OnlyFans creators ever, Killer Katrin couldn’t be excluded from our list of the best amateur OnlyFans babes either. Click the link below to discover her free page first.


10. Alexandra Rusu

alexandra rusu hot pictures

Alexandra Rusu, what a babe! This curvy redhead OnlyFans babe has a perfect booty, big boobs, and a pair of lovely, kissable lips. Her page is stocked full of amazing content (boy/girl and solo stuff), and she uploads new content every week, and replies to DMs every day. In fact, she prides herself on her fast response time. With over 1000 pieces of content uploaded, and a free gift when you subscribe, there really is no reason not to take this opportunity to sub to Alexandra for $6.99 a month.


11. Tasha Paige

tasha paige amateur OnlyFans

What an ass. Tasha Paige is a real beaut, lads! This blonde bombshell of an amateur OnlyFans babe has a perfect body, killer tats, and a smile that makes even the most stone-hearted men melt inside. Whether you’re looking for girl-on-girl, group sex, fetish stuff or solo play, Tasha can take care of you. She chats one-on-one with her fans every day, and takes the time to get to know us personally as much as she can. If you’d like to see this phat ass babe get down and dirty, subscribe to her account for $3.50 for the first 31 days.


12. Alli Avocado

alli avocado hot pictures

Who doesn’t love a good, sexy Latina OnlyFans model? Especially when she’s also a big boobed amateur OnlyFans queen? Seriously, Alli Avocado is absolutely incredible. This beautiful young Guatemalan college student specializes in lesbian OnlyFans content and solo play, her two favorite pastimes being eating pussy and playing with her own. Sexy, seductive, and all-round impressive, Alli doesn’t half-ass her OnlyFans, she puts her whole avocadussy into this stuff. Don’t believe me? Check out her account below for $13.99 a month.


13. Hope Aguilera

hope aguilera amateur OnlyFans

Hope Aguilera is a blonde, busty OnlyFans creator with perfect tits, and a passion for cock. Her amateur OnlyFans content is seriously impressive, and Hope doesn’t balk at much when it comes to filming her own porn. She describes herself as a “sassy, hazel-eyed, bombshell slut”, so what’s not to love? Hope uploads naughty content regularly, as well as provides the option to purchase PPV content, and she especially loves to chat in private to us, her adoring fans. If you’re anything like me, you’ll love chatting to hope, and for just $10 a month, you can.


14. Rhimarie

rhimarie milf sexy hot

Rhimarie is a gorgeous amateur OnlyFans creator, with supple skin, big, soft breasts, and thighs so delicious I’d like to smother myself in them. This beautiful mature OnlyFans babe has an extensive lingerie collection and eyes that scream “I want you, right now”, two things I always look for in a woman. Her page is full of incredible content, including some of the hottest pregnant OnlyFans content you could ever imagine. Rhimarie is hot, and she’s nasty as hell too: this babe loves to get filthy and try out every kink and fetish imaginable. Check out her page for $3.75 for the first month and see for yourself!


15. Viera May

amateur OnlyFans viera may

Viera May is stunning, sexy, and works hard to bring her loyal fans the best quality content possible. This submissive doll has a love for all things BDSM and kinky : she loves being walked like a dog, tied up and spanked, and all that good stuff. Viera has a cute yet seductive brunette vibe that we absolutely love, and she has over 2,5k photos uploaded to her page already, with tons of it being free to view. If you like kinky brunettes and want to get chatting to Viera, subscribe to her OnlyFans page below for just $5 a month.


16. Thick Mommy

thick mommy

If you enjoy all-American milfs, that post dirty, seductive, and all-round incredible amateur OnlyFans content, you’ll love Thick Mommy. This OnlyFans hotwife has a passion for cock and all things sex, and is a bit of a fireball in the bedroom. Thick Mommy does a wide variety of fun things on her page, such as threesomes, solo, and even some of the most amazing squirting OnlyFans videos you can imagine. This horny milf doesn’t hold back, and everything she does is incredible. Wanna see for yourself? Subscribe to Thick Mommy for just $9.99 a month below.


17. Sweet Aryana

sweet aryana live streamer amateur OnlyFans

Sweet Aryana in mainly a livestreamer, but has also opened an amateur OnlyFans account for her videos and pictures, and we’re very grateful. This beautiful blonde babe is a real freak in the sheets, and it doesn’t take much to convince her to get naked and show us the goods. Aryana gives free gifts to subscribers who take out a bundle (3, 6 or 12 months), so don’t be shy. She also loves to chat it up in the DMs, too. Aryana doesn’t do boy/girl, but does have a huge amount of solo videos, including toys, squirting, dancing, fetish content and much more. See for yourself when you subscribe to Aryana for $16.99 for the first month.


18. Lillie Kuma

lillie kuma pictures

Lillie Kuma has the innocence and cute vibe of the hottest 18 year old OnlyFans creators, you would hardly believe she wasn’t a teen anymore. This beautiful petite OnlyFans star has soft, peachy skin and a really intensely innocent vibe, with cute, perky little tits. Lillie is really naughty though, so don’t be fooled: this stunning cutie posts exclusive, uncensored pictures and videos daily, and everything she uploads is of the highest quality. Check out Lillie Kuma’s hottest content on her amateur OnlyFans page below for $6 for the first month.


19. Bratty Kayla

bratty kayla hot pictures

Bratty Kayla is a tatted alt amateur OnlyFans babe with a gorgeous smile, thick thighs and a love of a good dicking down. She posts full, uncensored nudes features her incredible 36E boobs, as well as a huge amount of fun solo play videos. Kayla also sells access to her snapchat account and dick rates, and you can get access to all her best stuff on her VIP account ($12.99 a month), but below, we’ve linked Kayla’s free page, so you can “try before you buy” as it were. Kayla loves to chat in private, so shoot her a DM and see if she can rock your world.


20. Corrupt Violet

amateur OnlyFans chubby corrupt violet

Who doesn’t love a gorgeous, seductive and wild BBW OnlyFans star? Corrupt Violet, or simply Violet is a beautiful chubby babe with huge boobs that loves to get freaky… and we mean freaky! Violet has a breeding fetish, which is pretty cool, and she loves to get creampied. This seductive babe loves to roleplay too, and get really into her role. If you’d like to see Violet get bred on the reg, subscribe to her account below for $4.88 for the first month. It’s incredible how sexy and naughty she can get.